Abbie shoots the pyramid lever to trigger the booby trap. The whole place starts to crumble and they climb out as Andy gets knocked down and pummeled by falling pieces of ceiling. When they get out, Abbie mentions what Andy said about the map being used by Moloch to win the war. Ichabod says he keeps asking what he would do if Katrina weren’t involved. He decides to burn the map against his emotional pain and Abbie promises they will free Katrina.
Captain Irving’s daughter gets finger printed because her DNA was found on the reverend’s neck. It was made clear that “evil did it” was not going to suffice so Captain Irving confessed to killing both men.
Ichabod is feeling remorse as he relives memories of Katrina asking him to free her. He recreates the map from memory. He goes outside and believes that he is in a dream but it turns out he has come across some reenactment games. He buys another outfit just like his from the vendor selling uniforms. A little later, Henry Parrish comes in and tells Ichabod, Abbie, and Jenny about his dream of four white trees and Moloch raising creatures from out of the ground. He also saw a rider on a horse with a flaming sword riding towards a solar eclipse. They realize this is the War horseman. Henry says the calendar confirms there will be a solar eclipse on this day and Jenny chimes in that it’s been 13 years to the day since she and Abbie had their experience with Moloch. Henry says out loud what they all fear to be true, that war is coming to Sleepy Hollow today.
Abbie goes to the police station for the Captain’s hearing and finds out that he’s already been transferred upstate. An officer hands her an envelope he left behind for her. It looks to be logs of meetings between Knapp and Corbin. Abbie believes these could help them with finding the Saint’s name, another part of Moloch’s riddle. Abbie assigns Jenny to dig through the tapes to find something. Ichabod finds secret messages in Washington’ bible that indicate there is a binding spell that can keep the second horseman from entering the realm. They would need a witch and all the ones they’ve encountered are dead, which means they need Katrina. This is when he tells her of redrawing the map from his eidetic memory. She is not happy but realizes it can help them. He tells her he had no intention of using the map without her consent.
After hearing the plan for Abbie to use the map and purposely walk into purgatory for Ichabod’s wife, Jenny pulls her aside. They have a heart-to-heart and she tells Abbie she doesn’t want to lose her again (having lost her after they parted ways for so many years). Abbie tells her she’s tired of being scared and running. She wants to face Moloch. Abbie tells her to have faith. Jenny says she has more than faith, being a mental patient with a gun, and that she will hunt her down if she’s not back by sunset.
Ichabod, Abbie, and Henry walk through the woods and discuss what to do when they get to where they are going. Ichabod tells Abbie how Katrina visits the echo of Abbie’s ancestors’ church (every day to pray for their son’s soul), something she told him when he ended up there in The Golem episode. Henry warns the two that they will be offered temptations (like food or drink) and if they take any they will be stuck there forever.
