She wants to rethink it all after what she just witnessed; realizing Henry could have been killed. She asks Ichabod what he’s willing to do to keep everyone safe, even if it means sacrificing the idea of freeing Katrina. While they talk, we go back to Henry, seeing that his hand is healing. Right then, several minions pop in and attack the three. Ichabod concedes to Abbie that it’s all more dangerous than probably Washington imagined. He follows that by saying they must find the map or all may be lost.
The three put their heads together to figure out where Knapp may have hid the map. They figure the hex was put there to stop Moloch from gaining useful information. They decide the map must be near Washington’s grave. The Sin Eater recalls from his vision that Knapp was transporting a body in a boat, which they figure is Washington. They hope if they find Washington’s grave then they’ll find the map.
Meanwhile, Andy busts out of his cocoon in his new minion-like form. He yells “I am your servant!” and then a thick, dark voice comes out of his mouth saying, “Moloch shall rise and all his enemies shall fall”.
The trio is headed over the water to Bannerman’s Island which Washington used as a penal colony. While searching, Abbie asks the Sin Eater about a witness turning on the other. He tells her of a prophecy that was rejected from the Old Testament that says when the beast rises, one witness will surrender the other and neither will survive. He also warns her that prophecies have a nasty way of fulfilling themselves if you let them happen. Ichabod finds a large stone in the ground and Abbie helps him twist it a certain direction. After several suspenseful seconds pass, a piece of the ground shifts open, revealing stairs. The three walk down into the ground believing this to be Washington’s secret grave.
They are in an underground tomb and see a pyramid which looks too obvious to be Washington’s grave. Abbie reaches for a lever to open it but Ichabod stops her, assuming that the place is booby-trapped. He sees something that says “Cincinnatus”, a Roman aristocrat who was Washington’s hero. Ichabod opens it and out comes Washington’s coffin. They open it and we see Washington’s skeleton clutching the map. Ichabod is overwhelmed with emotion as he opens it, realizing it means he can free Katrina.
Just then, someone comes partially down the stairs and then jumps to the ground. He looks up and Abbie recognizes Andy’s face. She points a gun toward him but he runs over to her incredibly fast and grabs it. Ichabod approaches and with a speedy swing of his arm Andy knocks him to the ground. He grabs Abbie’s neck and is choking her asking for the map as she tries to talk him down, saying she knows the real Andy is in there somewhere, the man that protected her and loved her.
Right then, Henry puts his hand on Andy’s arm and flashes of Andy’s life temporarily disarm him. He goes to his knees and his voice goes back to normal. He tells Abbie to destroy the map because Moloch needs it to win the war. He begs her to release him if she ever felt anything and suddenly he yells as if the evil is creeping back in. It’s obvious that he can’t maintain control so Abbie stabs a tool through his head, making him fall to the ground. The three realize they are sealed inside and go further into the crypt to find a way out. Ichabod finds a Masonic symbol of ascension on a wall and pulls it out and pushes it into an empty slot. The wall starts to lift up but so does Andy.
